Who removes personal information when you license data to an AI buyer?
No rule we found says the seller or the buyer must remove personal information; the law sets a test, and the contract decides who does the work. In the one court-approved sale we found, Spirit Airlines hired an independent firm to do it and the buyer paid the fee. Published tool prices start at free open-source software; Google charges from $1.00 per GiB (one gibibyte, roughly one gigabyte) a month (read 22 Nov 2026).
What could your company's records earn? Get a range in 30 seconds. Free, no obligation.
Who removes personal information before data goes to an AI buyer?
We found no US federal or California rule that names the seller or the buyer as the one who must do it. The law sets a test instead: the records must not be reasonably linkable to a person. The contract decides who does the work.
In the one court-approved sale we found, an outside firm hired by the seller did it. Spirit Airlines, in bankruptcy, hired Tonic, a maker of de-identification software, as its "Deidentification Agent." A Tonic officer swore on 12 Nov 2026 that the records go to that agent, not to the buyer. The buyer pays Tonic's fee, which "does not depend on the outcome."
| Task | In the Spirit sale | What we suggest you ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Remove personal details | Outside agent hired by the seller | A named, independent provider |
| Pay the removal fee | The buyer | The contract says who pays |
| Check the result | Independent reviewer, chosen with the union | A sample you can read yourself |
| Promise not to re-identify | The buyer | The same promise, passed to later recipients |
| Leave out risky records | Health, drug test, discipline and ID records | Your own list of excluded records |
What did the court require in the Spirit Airlines sale?
Judge Sean Lane approved the $10 million sale to Google on 17 Nov 2026 (The Record, 18 Nov 2026). Google agreed to leave out health and medical data, drug and alcohol test results, safety and disciplinary records, and identity documents. It also agreed to review by an independent assessor chosen with the union, and to no attempt to re-identify anyone.
Airways added that the reviewer must examine the contractor's risk assessment before the data is certified. See the Spirit sale in detail.
What do regulators accept as removed?
Each regulator sets a test, not one method.
- US health rules (HHS): two methods. Safe Harbor removes 18 listed identifiers, such as names and street addresses. In Expert Determination, a person with statistical knowledge finds the risk "very small." HHS says the risk "is not zero."
- California: data is "deidentified" if it cannot reasonably be linked to a consumer. The business must also publicly commit not to re-identify and bind every recipient by contract.
- EU (GDPR Recital 26): data that extra information could link back is still personal data.
- UK (ICO): swapping names for codes is "pseudonymisation," and the data stays personal.
Our page on how personal information is removed explains each method.
Does my company have to pay, and what does it cost?
No rule we found makes the seller pay. In Spirit the buyer paid. A vendor's published rules say the seller should hire the provider, and that the provider is paid whether or not the sale closes. That is the vendor's view, and it sells the service.
Prices we read on 22 Nov 2026:
- Microsoft Presidio: free open-source software. Its FAQ says there is "no guarantee" it finds everything. Computing and staff time cost extra, with no published figure.
- Google Cloud Sensitive Data Protection: $1.00 per GiB a month to scan stored files, and $1.00 per GiB a month to de-identify them. Text sent through its API costs $3.00 per GiB to scan and $2.00 to de-identify, up to 1,024 GiB a month, and less above that. The first GiB each month is free.
- Amazon Comprehend: $0.0001 per 100 characters (Amazon's pricing examples; CloudZero, 4 May 2026), with a free tier of 50,000 units a month per service for 12 months. By our arithmetic, 1 billion characters costs $1,000.
- Tonic: the done-for-you service is "priced per dataset, based on size." Its price page shows no dollar figure.
- Expert determination: we found no published rate card. One vendor's blog (12 Jun 2026) estimates a few thousand dollars up to tens of thousands. That is an estimate, not a quote.
What should the contract say about personal information?
A law firm's alert (Nixon Peabody, 26 Oct 2026) says deal terms should cover de-identification, exclusions, deletion, audit and who bears the risk. Ask for these:
- Who removes the personal details, and to what standard.
- A certificate before each delivery, not only the first.
- A ban on re-identification that follows the data to every later holder.
- A right to audit, and a plan if personal details turn up later.
- Deletion rules. Deleting files "may not remove their influence from a trained model," so name what happens to the model.
We found no neutral model clause text. See the contract clauses to check.
What must I check before I share anything?
- Employees: California's privacy law covers employees and job applicants (California Privacy Protection Agency). See employee privacy and workplace chat.
- Customers: the FTC says quietly widening a privacy policy to allow AI training may be unfair or deceptive (13 Feb 2024).
- Rights: having data is not permission to license it. Notices and contracts limit you.
- Free text: names are harder to find in email and chat than in a database. Test a sample first.
See AI training data privacy rules. To check everything in one pass, use our data self-audit.
Questions
Can the buyer remove personal information instead of us?
A contract can allow it, but we found no published terms showing how often it happens. Ask who touches the raw records.
Is pseudonymised data the same as anonymous data?
No. Under the GDPR and the UK ICO, replacing names with codes leaves the data personal.
Is removal free?
Open-source tools cost nothing to download. Cloud services charge by volume.
Does removing names make the data safe to license?
Not alone. HHS says the risk is "not zero." Exclude sensitive categories and add an independent check.
Sources
This page is general education, not legal advice. Ask a lawyer to review your own deal.
- U.S. Bankruptcy Court, S.D.N.Y., In re Spirit Aviation Holdings, Doc 1814, Declaration of a Tonic officer, 12 Nov 2026: https://document.epiq11.com/document/getdocumentbycode?docId=4630346&projectCode=SPJ&source=DM
- The Record from Recorded Future News, "Judge signs off on sale of Spirit Airlines' data to Google", 18 Nov 2026: https://therecord.media/judge-signs-off-google-purchase-spirit-airlines-data
- Airways, "Judge Approves Google's US$10 Million Purchase of Spirit Airlines Data", 18 Nov 2026: https://www.airwaysmag.com/new-post/judge-approves-google-spirit-airlines-data-sale
- Nixon Peabody LLP, "Shopping for AI training data? Five diligence questions before you buy", 26 Oct 2026: https://www.nixonpeabody.com/insights/alerts/2026/10/26/shopping-for-ai-training-data-five-diligence-questions-before-you-buy
- Tonic.ai, "De-Identification Tenets for AI Data Licensing", 23 Sep 2026 (a vendor's view): https://www.tonic.ai/blog/de-identification-ai-data-licensing
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, "Guidance Regarding Methods for De-identification of Protected Health Information", read 22 Nov 2026: https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/special-topics/de-identification/index.html
- California Legislature, Civil Code 1798.140 (definition of "deidentified"), read 22 Nov 2026: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CIV§ionNum=1798.140.
- General Data Protection Regulation, Recital 26, read 22 Nov 2026: https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-26/
- UK Information Commissioner's Office, "Introduction to anonymisation", read 22 Nov 2026: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/data-sharing/anonymisation/introduction-to-anonymisation
- California Privacy Protection Agency, "Frequently Asked Questions", read 22 Nov 2026: https://cppa.ca.gov/faq.html
- Federal Trade Commission, "AI (and other) Companies: Quietly Changing Your Terms of Service Could Be Unfair or Deceptive", 13 Feb 2024: https://www.ftc.gov/policy/advocacy-research/tech-at-ftc/2024/02/ai-other-companies-quietly-changing-your-terms-service-could-be-unfair-or-deceptive
- Google Cloud, "Sensitive Data Protection pricing", read 22 Nov 2026: https://cloud.google.com/sensitive-data-protection/pricing
- Amazon Web Services, "Amazon Comprehend pricing", read 22 Nov 2026: https://aws.amazon.com/comprehend/pricing/
- CloudZero, "Amazon Comprehend Pricing: A Complete Guide (2026)", 4 May 2026: https://www.cloudzero.com/blog/amazon-comprehend-pricing
- Microsoft, "Presidio" (open-source project), read 22 Nov 2026: https://github.com/microsoft/presidio
- Tonic.ai, "Pricing", read 22 Nov 2026: https://www.tonic.ai/pricing
- Limina, "The Cost of Expert Determination: What to Budget and What to Avoid", 12 Jun 2026 (a vendor's estimate): https://www.getlimina.ai/en/blog/hipaa-expert-determination-cost