How do you compare data licensing offers?
Compare offers on seven terms, not only the headline price: exclusivity, term, permitted use, who de-identifies, the payment trigger, the deletion right and what you must promise. Convert each offer to a first-year, no-risk value so the numbers line up.
What could your company's records earn? Get a range in 30 seconds. Free, no obligation.
Why is the headline price a poor guide?
Two offers of the same size can differ widely in value. One may be exclusive and perpetual, another non-exclusive for two years. One pays on delivery, another after an "acceptance" that has no deadline. Public buyers publish licenses from about $10,000 to $4,000,000 per company (buyer program pages, read 20 to 21 Nov 2026), so a range that wide hides large differences in terms.
Cold pitches add noise. A journalist received emails promising "$350K to $1.8M" as a one-time fee (Wired, 6 Nov 2026). A range with no scope attached is not an offer. See red flags and scam offers.
What are the seven terms to compare?
| Term | Better for you | Worse for you |
|---|---|---|
| Exclusivity | Non-exclusive, or short and narrow | Exclusive and perpetual |
| Term | Fixed years | Perpetual |
| Permitted use | Training and testing the buyer's own models | Any use, any product |
| Resale | Named labs only, or none | Unlimited resale |
| De-identification | Done before any lab sees the records, with independent check | "Commercially reasonable efforts" |
| Payment trigger | On delivery, or fixed window such as 30 days | Open-ended acceptance, claw-backs |
| Your promises | You own what you share, to your knowledge | You guarantee no personal data anywhere |
Each row maps to a clause in the 10 contract clauses to check.
What does a worked comparison look like?
The three offers below are invented examples, built to show the method. They are not real offers. Assume a company with 60 staff and eight years of email and chat.
| Offer A (example) | Offer B (example) | Offer C (example) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headline price | $600,000 | $350,000 | $220,000 a year, 3 years |
| Exclusive | Yes, perpetual | No | No |
| Payment | After "acceptance", no deadline | On delivery | On delivery each year |
| Resale | Unlimited | Named labs only | None |
| De-identification | Buyer, no check | Buyer, independent check | Buyer, independent check |
| Deletion | None | At end of 3 years | At end of term |
Offer A has the biggest number and the worst terms. You lose all later licensing of those records, and payment has no date. Offer B pays $350,000 now and lets you sell the same records again. Offer C pays $660,000 over three years if the buyer renews each year, but only the first year is committed.
How do I turn offers into the same number?
Use a simple score. For each offer, write the first-year cash you can count on, then subtract what you give up.
| Step | Offer A | Offer B | Offer C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash you can count on in year 1 | $0 until accepted | $350,000 | $220,000 |
| Add a second license you could sign | $0 (exclusive) | likely more than $0 | likely more than $0 |
| Privacy and resale risk | High | Low | Lowest |
| Verdict | Ask for a deadline and non-exclusive price | Strong | Strong if the 3-year term is binding |
The point of the table is the pattern: price alone ranks A first; terms rank it last. The numbers are invented.
How many offers should I collect?
At least three. Competing offers give leverage on exclusivity, term and the payment trigger. A broker can collect several for you, and you should ask each buyer for a non-exclusive price. See how long the process takes before you plan the timing, and the calculator for a range to test offers against.
What questions should I ask every buyer?
- What is your price for a non-exclusive, fixed-term license?
- Who removes personal details, and who checks?
- Can you resell, and to whom?
- What triggers payment, and by what date?
- Do you delete the records at the end, and will you confirm in writing?
- Can you name a reference who has been paid?
A buyer that will not answer is telling you something.
Questions
Should I always take the highest offer?
No. A high price with perpetual exclusivity and no payment date can be worth less than a lower offer with clean terms.
What if I get only one offer?
Ask for changes to exclusivity, term and the payment trigger, and get a lawyer's review before you sign.
Can I negotiate after an offer?
Yes. Indicative ranges are not binding, and terms are usually negotiable.
Do these example offers show real prices?
No. They are invented to show the method.
Sources
- Wired, Steven Levy, 6 Nov 2026 (the article names buyers, so this site does not link it).
- Published buyer program pages and estimators, read 20 and 21 Nov 2026 (buyers not named by policy).
- Clause checklist: this site's 10 contract clauses.
- This page is general education, not legal or financial advice. The three offers are examples, not data.